I wrote today at WHYY on Lakewood Public Schools’ fiscal insolvency, a problem largely due the cost of busing 25,000 private day school students to Orthodox Jewish yeshivas. There’s another article in today’s Asbury Park Press which details the strains of transportation on the district, where the 4,800 attending public school students (mostly Hispanic and mostly poor) are given short-shrift by a school board beholden to the Jewish community. Cost this year for busing is over $21 million, a fifth of the total operating budget, including $6.8 million to bus 10,000 yeshiva students to schools within two miles of their homes under the policy of “courtesy busing.”
Perhaps no issue reflects the divide in town as much as the cost and necessity of courtesy busing — and that division is reflected on the school board.
On Aug. 29, Board President Carl Fink got into a heated verbal exchange with board members Zechariah Greenspan and Yisrael Friedman over requesting that their own children receive front-door service from the school bus.
Fink, saying he was confident that he would not be re-elected because his views were unpopular in the township’s Jewish community — a powerful voting bloc — told Friedman and Greenspan that “the amount of children that get busing for nonpublic schools that live a block away is disgraceful. We did away with house stops. Now you two gentlemen, who are on the board, asked (the district) to make house stops. Shame on you.”
The room burst out in applause.
What Fink was objecting to was Friedman and Greenspan requesting that an exception be made so that their children would be picked up at their house — a practice the board had banned for the rest of the township.
This is a statement by Paula White, Executive Director of JerseyCAN, on the New Jersey…
This is a press release. Earlier today, Gov. Phil Murphy signed a bill to eliminate…
Today Gov. Phil Murphy signed Senate Bill 896, which prohibits the New Jersey Department of…
The 74 conducted a study of the relative learning loss in Democratic (Blue) and Republican (Red) states and…
In October 2020 Newark Superintendent Roger Leon announced with great fanfare the opening of district’s…
This is a press release from the Governor's Office. In related news, one in five…
View Comments
Why is it acceptable for a child who lives in Hillsborough to get bussed to Pingry or a child who lives in Princeton to get bussed to Lawrence Academy, but not for a child who lives in Lakewood to get bussed to a yeshiva? Why do you constantly object to religious children being bussed to religious private schools but you, as far as I know, have never objected to a secular child being bussed to a secular prep school?
Lakewood's schools are not insolvent (an exaggeration) because they bus three-quarters of their kids to private schools. If those children attended public schools the system would be insolvent. Districts in New Jersey spend $880 in private school bussing per student or provide a bus, whichever is less costly. Per pupil spending in New Jersey public schools was above $15,000 a year. A child's attendance in a private school saves a public school district a huge amount of money.
If the yeshiva kids in Lakewood attended private school Lakewood's finances would be stretched even tighter. State aid to Lakewood would increase. Eventual state pension costs for the extra Lakewood public school teachers would be millions of dollars a year.
If you object to transportation subsidies then object to subsidies to ALL private school students, not just Jewish ones.