Categories: General

QOD: Students Benefitted from Bloomberg’s Strategy of Closing Failing High Schools

From PoliticoPro:

The closures of struggling New York City high schools yielded benefits for middle schoolers who might otherwise have enrolled there, according to a report released Thursday by NYU’s Research Alliance for New York City Schools

The report will likely provide ammunition for Mayor Bill de Blasio’s education critics – chief among them charter school advocates – who say the city is harming students by not shuttering chronically struggling schools. 

De Blasio and schools chancellor Carmen Fariña have said that under the nearly $400 million Renewal Schools program, they will close low-performing schools only as a last resort. They have said they will give struggling schools three years, or in some cases less time, to improve with academic interventions. 

School closure was one of the most controversial aspects of former mayor Michael Bloomberg’s sweeping education reforms, but the NYU study found the policy was largely effective for the students who would have attended those struggling high schools that were closed.

If you don’t subscribe, you can see similar stories in other media outlets.

From Chalkbeat:

Despite the backlash, high school graduation rates improved under Bloomberg, and this latest study suggests that individual students fared better as a result of the school closures. Former Bloomberg officials seized on the report as another vindication of their approach, while opponents such as the city teachers union downplayed the findings.

From the Wall St. Journal:

The study from the Research Alliance for New York City Schools at New York University aims to add data to the highly charged issue of how to address the lowest-performing schools. In contrast to his predecessor, Mayor Bill de Blasio has said shutting struggling schools will be a last resort: A year ago, he announced a $150 million, three-year plan to turn around 94 “renewal schools” by adding social services, longer school days and teacher training, among other steps.

No leader likes to close community schools. It’s political kryptonite, a drop-dead trigger for allergic responses from special interest groups invested in traditional power structures. Former Mayor Mike Bloomberg closed 22 N.Y.C. high schools between 2003-2009 (Chalkbeat has a list) and certainly suffered political backlash. But how can an educational leader do anything else when incontrovertible evidence proves that the hard course is the right course?

There’s some lessons here for Mayor de Blasio and Chancellor Farina.

Laura Waters

View Comments

  • From the report itself: "Third, while this study shows clear gains for students in the wake of a closure, these students still did not fare well". And the other: "While the report documents improvements in some of the City's lowest performing schools, it cannot tell us whether similar gains in student outcomes could have been attained without closures."
    Hardly incontrovertible evidence.

Recent Posts

BREAKING: Statement from JerseyCAN on State’s Long-Delayed Release of Student Test Results

This is a statement by Paula White, Executive Director of JerseyCAN, on the New Jersey…

2 years ago

NJEA: Murphy’s Elimination of Teacher Performance Test Is a Major Win for Students and Educators

This is a press release. Earlier today, Gov. Phil Murphy signed a bill to eliminate…

2 years ago

Murphy Signs Bill Eliminating EdTPA Test for Teacher Certification

Today Gov. Phil Murphy signed Senate Bill 896, which prohibits the New Jersey Department of…

2 years ago

LILLEY: Blue States Had More School Closures and More Learning Loss — Just Like NJ under Gov. Murphy

The 74 conducted a study of the relative learning loss in Democratic (Blue) and Republican (Red) states and…

2 years ago

One of Newark Superintendent’s New High Schools Tolerates Racism Against Black Students

In October 2020 Newark Superintendent Roger Leon announced with great fanfare the opening of district’s…

2 years ago