On Sunday TapintoNewark ran a piece that describes how over the last ten years “the state agency responsible for building schools in 31 former Abbott districts has spent more than $263 million to build five schools in Newark at a cost that far exceeded the limits set by the Legislature.” This agency is, of course, the scandal-ridden Schools Development Authority which is responsible for building and renovating school buildings in New Jersey’s Abbott districts. In contrast to a recent North Jersey hit-job (which I unraveled here) this most recent coverage accurately unpacks the SDA’s wanton profligacy — your tax dollars at work: For example, “the SDA spent more than a quarter of a billion dollars to build schools for only 3,733 Newark children — an average of more than $70,000 per student.”
In response to these revelations former Camden Superintendent Paymon Rouhanifard tweeted out his thoughts about this “must-read for policy makers & anyone concerned about public education,” including how New Jersey charter schools build schools at far less expense (with a well-deserved dig at the North Jersey piece I cited above). Former Newark Superintendent Cami Anderson added her thoughts too. Both take aim at NJ’s failure to fairly fund facilities for charter schools. Here’s the full thread for your edification.
This informative @TAPintoNewark piece about the cost of new school construction by the NJ School Development Authority should be a must-read for policy makers & anyone concerned about public education. Yet I worry it won't garner much attention.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
1/ https://t.co/9jz6Sopc8C
Spending ~$70 million on a new elementary school is indefensible. Taxpayers deserve better. And most of all, other students still waiting in decrepit buildings for funds to come through are suffering the consequences.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
2/
So often the conversation about underfunded schools focuses on per pupil spending. Yet poor conditions inside of schools – like those recently described by a report on Providence – have more to do with capital investments, which is distinct from per pupil dollars.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
3/
In Camden, we were able to partner with non-profit charter organizations to build phenomenal buildings kids deserve at less than half the rate — and time — it took the SDA to construct these other traditional public schools. And we used union labor!
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
4/
I don't normally do this, but it's just incredibly frustrating to recall the pushback we received on renaissance schools, and then be reminded of these details of the only alternative available to those in opposition.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
5/
And the press, as far as I can tell, rarely amplifies this matter. Instead, you get asinine pieces like this one from the Bergen Record — 10K words to describe a complex tax scheme some non-profit Newark charters used to build affordable buildings.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
6/https://t.co/5V3Wo2NhIV
Mind you, Newark charters don't even receive facilities / capital funding like traditional public schools do, which is why they have to rely on these complicated tax structures to begin with.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
7/
Look, capital repairs for neglected school districts is an incredibly complicated matter, and I'm not here to proffer overly simplistic solutions like just let more charters build. But the knowledge gap on this issue is profound.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
8/
I just wish the conversation about school funding was about a baseline level of *resources* all kids deserve. And how do we get there through both an operating and capital budget — and with the right balance of efficiency and public accountability.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
9/
Last thing: tired arguments about stagnant proficiency rates in spite of spending $whatever/per pupil miss the point. But I can tell you the folks screaming for more funds often aren't willing to address this staggering lack of efficiency & accountability.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 8, 2019
10/10
Charters and traditional schools in Newark are VASTLY underfunded when it comes to facilities. Long term construction, envelop health, major repair to be handled by the state w/ public schools getting paltry amount for maintenance. Over time, has led to unacceptable conditions.
— Cami #WeHaveHerBack Anderson (@theCamiAnderson) July 8, 2019
A report commissioned by my administration circa 2013 showed it would cost 1B to make Newark schools relatively 21st century-ready (only if some uninhabitable schools were closed)…because of decades of neglect and underfunding. Agree it need to be part of convo for all schools.
— Cami #WeHaveHerBack Anderson (@theCamiAnderson) July 8, 2019
So the fact that 1/4 of a billion was spent on one school is just head spinning. There’s got to be a batter way.
— Cami #WeHaveHerBack Anderson (@theCamiAnderson) July 9, 2019
It’s insane. Worst combination of inefficiency and lack accountability. They’ve essentially been doing this for decades and nothing has changed.
— Paymon Rouhanifard (@Rouhanifard) July 9, 2019